Posted on

Is the spiritual disconnected from reality?

Once in a while, one can find a thoughtful blog post about church issues of grave concern. One pithy quote (or cliche) that has circulated is: “too heavenly minded to be of any earthly good.” This blogger writes about the disconnect from the pulpit to current events, and the corresponding disconnect of spiritual life and human decisions & understanding, particularly in his experience of the Chinese church in North America.

Led by the Spirit: The Stagnation of Christian Growth

I recently visited a friend whom I have not seen for a long time. We had a wonderful fellowship time sharing what God has been doing in our lives. During our conversation, the subject of Chinese church in North America was brought up. More and more Christians have been questioning the disconnection of church ministry and the world. Messages from the pulpit seem to be missing the heartbeat of the congregation. My friend observed that with the global economy in shambles and the OBCs fixing their vision on the trial of the former Taiwan President for corruption, the pulpit has offered not a single word on the spiritual perspectives on these issues.

… The analysis he concluded with was theological. He suspected that while Chinese Christians emphasized so much on being led by the Spirit, eventually it became an excuse for the stagnation of personal growth because of the lacking of reflection.

… While my friend observed some American churches continued to grow, the good news really belongs to the minority. Most churches, American or Chinese, still struggle with internal and external issues.

… The general culture in the church ascribes the work of the Spirit to supernaturalism. When it comes to “spiritual matters”, the understood consensus dictates that the less involvement of human decision the better. … Gradually, ignorance equals spiritual maturity.

Now, his experience is similiar to mine. It makes me wonder, though, does this over-spiritualizing and anti-intellectualism happen in other non-Chinese ethnic-Asian churches? What can be done to remedy this?

I’ll reveal a peek into my latest tentative thoughts about why the church has to do the work of contextualizing faith in ethnic & cultural context, why there needs to be churches adapted to include Asian Americans, why there needs to be Asian Americans doing theology, why there needs to be Asian Americans in leadership. In other words, it’s not enough to say that we’re all human, we’re all spiritual in Christ, we can just follow Christ by reading the Bible, praying and obeying.

I won’t write a long treatise about it. I’ll say it this way, in one word: incarnation.


About djchuang

Strengthen your brand with an instant association with the Bible - get one at

One response to “Is the spiritual disconnected from reality?

  1. elderj

    Thank you. Thank you so much for putting words to the indistinct and heretofore unarticulated feelings. As I’ve worshipped these last few years in an Asian ethnic church, I have wondered what it was that felt disconnected. You’ve hit the nail on the head here. I find a deep longing for the gospel to make sense of life, and yet a deep seated discomfort with doing the work needed to do just that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s